California’s New Arbitration Law: What It Means for You, and When You Should Talk to a Lawyer

California introduced a major change in 2025 that could reshape how everyday people resolve disputes with companies. Under the new law, SB 940, consumers now have stronger rights when facing unfair arbitration clauses in contracts. If you’ve ever felt like a business forced you into an agreement you didn’t fully understand, this law might give you new legal options — and in some cases, the ability to bring your dispute to court rather than private arbitration.

Arbitration has long been used by corporations because it’s cheaper, private, and often more favorable to them than courtroom litigation. Many people don’t even realize they agreed to arbitration until something goes wrong. This new legislation pushes back on that imbalance, giving Californians more control and transparency when dealing with service providers, landlords, telecom companies, subscription services, and other businesses that rely on standard contracts.


What Changed Under SB 940

Before SB 940, arbitration clauses in consumer contracts were often enforceable regardless of how they were presented. These clauses were usually buried in long, dense contract language that most people never read in full. Companies used them to block lawsuits, prevent consumers from joining class actions, and avoid public accountability. Even when the clause was unfair or one-sided, courts frequently upheld it because the consumer had technically “agreed” to the terms by signing or clicking “accept.”

SB 940 shifts that landscape. Now, certain arbitration clauses can be voided if they were part of a contract of adhesion — meaning the consumer had no meaningful way to negotiate the terms. This includes the vast majority of contracts people interact with daily: phone plans, gym memberships, home services, streaming platforms, and rental agreements. If the arbitration clause is found to be unconscionable or misleading, California courts may allow the consumer to bypass arbitration entirely.

Another major aspect of the law is that companies may face attorney’s fees if they try to enforce an arbitration clause that turns out to be illegal under this new framework. That creates a powerful deterrent: businesses now need to think twice before slipping overreaching or confusing arbitration language into their contracts. For consumers, it means more leverage and more opportunities to challenge unfair agreements.


Why This Matters Now (And Who It Helps)

Arbitration clauses have been controversial for years because they often shield companies from accountability. When disputes go to arbitration instead of court, the process is private, the decisions are not public record, and consumers usually face an uphill battle. Many arbitration providers rely on repeat business from the same companies, which creates an uneven playing field.

The new law levels things out. It’s especially important for people who interact with companies through standard-form contracts — which is practically everyone. Tenants, gym members, healthcare consumers, online shoppers, phone users, and subscription customers all benefit from having more opportunities to challenge unfair contract terms.

This law is also significant for people dealing with financial harm, hidden fees, or misleading service agreements. In the past, companies relied on arbitration clauses to avoid facing class actions or jury trials, even when they engaged in widespread misconduct. SB 940 weakens that shield. For certain disputes, consumers may now be able to bring claims directly to court, where they can access broader discovery, public hearings, and potentially higher compensation.

Overall, the law gives everyday Californians more bargaining power and more confidence that the system won’t automatically tilt in the company’s favor.


What This Means for Companies (Including Small Businesses)

For businesses that rely on standardized contracts, SB 940 is more than a procedural change — it’s a prompt to rethink contract strategy entirely. Companies can no longer assume that arbitration clauses will automatically protect them from lawsuits. If those clauses are overly restrictive, buried in fine print, or presented as non-negotiable, they may be struck down.

This affects not only big corporations but also local service providers, landlords, property managers, online retailers, and small businesses that use template contracts. Many businesses will need to review their agreements with legal counsel, revise dispute-resolution sections, and ensure that customers understand what they’re signing. A poorly drafted arbitration clause is no longer just ineffective — it can expose the company to litigation costs and penalties.

Businesses should also expect an increase in court litigation. Disputes that once would have been forced into arbitration may now proceed through the public court system, which can be more expensive and time-consuming. Companies that rely on arbitration to limit costs, damage awards, or class actions may need to prepare for a new reality: one where consumers have greater access to traditional legal remedies.

What You Should Do — As a Consumer

If you’ve signed a contract recently (or in the last few years) with any kind of company for services — whether telecom, housing, subscriptions, home repairs, fitness, health-related, or something similar — take these steps:

  1. Read the fine print: Look for arbitration clauses, forced arbitration language, or terms that require disputes be resolved in another state or by a specific arbitrator.
  2. Ask: is this a “take-it-or-leave-it” contract? Courts often view standard-form consumer contracts more skeptically now under SB 940.
  3. If you think you were misled or harmed, consider contacting an attorney — this law could allow you to challenge unfair clauses and pursue full remedies in court.
  4. Keep records: Save your original agreement, all communications, payments, and related documents — if you challenge the clause or bring a legal claim, documentation is key.

What You Should Do — As a Business (Service Provider, Landlord, Vendor, etc.)

If you draft or use contracts with California consumers:

  • Review all existing contracts and consumer-service agreements.
  • Remove or revise dubious arbitration clauses that may no longer be enforceable.
  • Add clear disclosures about dispute-resolution rights.
  • After updating, consider having contracts reviewed by legal counsel to ensure they comply with SB 940 and avoid future litigation risks.

Why This Law Matters for Californians — And What It Reflects

SB 940 is part of a broader trend in California of re-balancing power toward consumers and workers, and pushing back against opaque, one-sided business practices. Over the last couple of years, the state has passed laws expanding worker protections, regulating emerging technologies, and strengthening consumer rights.

For consumers, this might feel like a small shift — but in practice, it can open real doors. Lawsuits no longer have to be funneled into private arbitration, and individuals now have more leverage to challenge unfair contract terms.

For businesses, it’s a reminder that compliance and fairness are not optional. Contracts can’t simply bury consumer rights in small print or force an unfair path for dispute resolution anymore.


When to Contact a Lawyer

If any of the following applies to you, you might want to consult with an attorney:

  • You signed a contract requiring arbitration and now want to challenge it.
  • You believe a company’s actions violated your consumer rights — especially if the contract has ambiguous or unfair dispute-resolution terms.
  • You run a business and need to update your contracts to comply with SB 940 and avoid lawsuits.

Our firm has experience reviewing contracts, challenging unfair arbitration clauses, and representing Californians whose rights were compromised by forced-arbitration or misleading contract language.


Final Thoughts

For a long time, arbitration clauses gave companies a nearly unchallengeable advantage over regular people. Now, with SB 940, California is giving power back to consumers — and giving businesses a reason to play fair.

If you or someone you know has signed a contract recently, it’s worth re-reading it carefully. That fine print could make all the difference.

And if you want help figuring out whether you’re still bound by arbitration — or looking at your legal options — reach out. It might change everything.